HomeBest & Compare › Deer-resistant shade flowers for zone 4

Deer-resistant shade flowers for zone 4

3 of 85 flowers qualified

V Written by Editorial TeamEdited by Vladimir

The winner: Hellebore, 93/100. Runner-up: Virginia Bluebells at 79.

Every flower here is scored by the same 5 published rules, using one open table of 85 flowers. No taste, no sponsors: tap any score and it unfolds into the lines that made it.

The picks

The flowers that won

The top score, plus the qualifier that asks least of you.

Hellebore 9393WINNERWINNERYFG INDEX

Hellebore ↗

Deer resistance strength: A · Shade fitness: part shade, full shade · Cold reach: 4 to 9

Flaws, not dealbreakers: toxic to cats

Deer: rarely damaged (Rutgers A) Not for cat households
93/ 100tap for the breakdown
Deer resistance strength35 / 35A
Shade fitness25 / 25part shade, full shade
Cold reach16 / 204 to 9
Bloom window9 / 123 months
Set-and-forget upkeep8 / 8low
Virginia Bluebells 7979LOW-EFFORT PICKLOW-EFFORT PICKYFG INDEX

Virginia Bluebells ↗

Deer resistance strength: B · Shade fitness: full shade, part shade · Cold reach: 3 to 9

Flaws, not dealbreakers: asks for some seasonal upkeep; the show is short, about 2 months

Deer: seldom damaged (Rutgers B)
79/ 100tap for the breakdown
Deer resistance strength24 / 35B
Shade fitness25 / 25full shade, part shade
Cold reach20 / 203 to 9
Bloom window6 / 122 months
Set-and-forget upkeep4 / 8medium

Also great

Close behind on points. Neither beats the winner overall, but each is the better answer in a garden the winner would not suit.

Cyclamen 6969ALSO GREATALSO GREATYFG INDEX

Cyclamen

Deer resistance strength: B · Shade fitness: part shade, full shade · Cold reach: 9 to 11

Flaws, not dealbreakers: asks for some seasonal upkeep; toxic to cats

Deer: seldom damaged (Rutgers B) Not for cat households
69/ 100tap for the breakdown
Deer resistance strength24 / 35B
Shade fitness25 / 25part shade, full shade
Cold reach4 / 209 to 11
Bloom window12 / 125 months
Set-and-forget upkeep4 / 8medium
The protocol

How the score is built

5 rules, 100 points, no opinions. Every line reads one field of the table.

Deer resistance strength35 pointsrarely damaged 35; seldom severely damaged 24 Read from: the Rutgers deer rating.
Shade fitness25 pointsthrives in deep shade 25 Read from: the light it is documented in.
Cold reach20 pointsRead straight from the zones it survives.
Bloom window12 pointsRead straight from the months it is in bloom.
Set-and-forget upkeep8 pointsRead straight from how much upkeep extension guides report.

Not ranked here: needs more light than a shade bed offers; a full-sun plant that merely tolerates shade; not rated deer-resistant by Rutgers (A or B). Scores are never sponsored and never sold. The full method ↗

The leaderboard

Every qualifier, ranked

The 3 highest of 3 that qualified. Tap any score to open the lines behind it.

1Hellebore
93/ 100tap for the breakdown
Deer resistance strength35 / 35A
Shade fitness25 / 25part shade, full shade
Cold reach16 / 204 to 9
Bloom window9 / 123 months
Set-and-forget upkeep8 / 8low
2Virginia Bluebells
79/ 100tap for the breakdown
Deer resistance strength24 / 35B
Shade fitness25 / 25full shade, part shade
Cold reach20 / 203 to 9
Bloom window6 / 122 months
Set-and-forget upkeep4 / 8medium
3Cyclamen
Cyclamen
69/ 100tap for the breakdown
Deer resistance strength24 / 35B
Shade fitness25 / 25part shade, full shade
Cold reach4 / 209 to 11
Bloom window12 / 125 months
Set-and-forget upkeep4 / 8medium

Considered, not chosen

Not qualifying is a verdict too: the table simply says this job is not theirs.

a full-sun plant that merely tolerates shadePeonies, Lily, Dahlia and 56 more
needs more light than a shade bed offersRoses, Tulips, Sunflower and 11 more
not rated deer-resistant by Rutgers (A or B)Hydrangea macrophylla, Anthurium, Azaleas and 6 more

The winner's badge

Generated by the ranking above, and re-scored whenever the table changes.

Hellebore

The badge is generated by this ranking, not awarded by hand. When the table changes, it re-scores itself.

9393DEER-PROOF SHADEDEER-PROOF SHADEYFG INDEX · WINNER
How we rank

We keep one table of 85 flowers, with 25 documented facts each, drawn from university and extension sources. Every ranking is a published formula worth 100 points; tap any score and it unfolds into the lines that made it. A flower that does not fit a job is not scored lower: it is excluded, and the reason is named. Nothing here is sponsored, and no score can be bought. When the table changes, every score and stamp updates itself. The full method ↗

All nominations The table behind the scores